Would you rather ... Jesus Montero for Clayton Kershaw
The final vote was 19-6 in favor of doing the deal, and here are all of the 25 votes, as transcribed from the Twitter.
The Responses: Yes votes
Crowny3: Of course.
Mwash1983: Absolutely do it, Kershaw pitched better on the road than at home this season
PhilHughesFan: That's a no-brainer. Of course the Dodgers wouldn't do it.
Dpatrickg: I vote yes, if Montero's the only of the Yankees top 6 or 7 prospects going to L.A.
JoePawl: Make that six (yes votes).
HammerF: Make it six (although he was actually seven).
LeoKitty: Yes plz re: Kershaw trade.
JayDestro: All hangs on control (contract-wise), but leaning toward yes.
PPinstripes: I agree with Joe, especially because Kershaw is established and ridiculously young himself.
Rebexarama: Thought about it, I think I'd do it. Neither is 100,000% proven, obviously, but at least Kershaw's been in the majors.
mikeaxisa: Kershaw and I wouldn't think twice about it.
Yankees_N_More: ABSOLUTELY YES! But only if I couldn't find a way to go get King Felix.
TheYankeeU: Absolutely. And I doubt you'll find a bigger Montero booster than me.
Heelsonthefield: I'll throw my vote in. Quality pitching trumps anything and everything. Yes to trade. Very dependent on terms of deal though.
GreggFerrara: Count me in as trade Jesus for the young lefty K machine.
OSingh91: I am a huge prospect hugger, but I'd easily take Kershaw. Love starting lefties that miss a lot of bats.
Joe_DelGrippo: Tough choice as I love Montero, but Kershaw is too good to pass on. Picked him at beginning of year as my Cy Young dark horse.
TheBronxView: I wouldn't, just because I want to see the Yankees develop a big power bat. Trade would make sense for the Yanks, though.
Stevensmithy: I really like Montero, and I don't care a TON for Kershaw. He can look very pedestrian at times in a weak-hitting division.
AndyinSunnyDB: Make that three for Montero. To steal a poker term, I'm going all in with him. Legends live forever.
Yankees666: No. Laura Posada said that Jorge will dh, so it's Montero time in the Bronx.
Cephster: Going to say no as well. Would only trade Montero for a sure thing, and Kershaw ain't it.